As you like it - Harry Potter

[Pardona]

The Leaky Cauldron

Tonks or Lupin?

[Regan]

Lupin (boo Tonks)

Fawkes or Hedwig?

[hpfanfiction]

Hedwig- RIP
Severus or Sirius?

[May]

Sirius

Pavarti or Lavender?

[Regan]

Sirius

That's ain't cool.

Lavender (what does Parvati even do?)

Nagini or Wormtail?

[Rachel]

nagini

history of magic or divination?

[Regan]

Divination (plus sherry)

Nargles or Wrackspurts?

[Pardona]

Nargles ('tis the season - almost)

Trying to capture the Golden Egg or trying to rescue 'Master's Wheezy'?

[Regan]

Golden Egg ( )

Luna Lovegood or Ginny Weasley?

[Ammer]

Luna.

Ginny's annoying.

Young Voldemort or Old Voldemort?

[hpfanfiction]

Young Voldemort- I can *almost* empathise with the 10-year old Tom at the orphanage- but Old Voldy is completely inhuman and evil with no redeeming or sympathetic qualities
Hermione or Ginny?

[Evil Stu Man]

Hermione - She's more cooler than Ginny.

Crabbe or Goyle?

[Pardona]

Crabbe - RIP

Ginny's singing Get-Well card, or Lavender Brown's 'My Sweetheart' Medaillon?

[hpfanfiction]

Ginny's "Your eyes are as green as a fresh pickled toad....." x) please- at least she was young at the time- can't say the same for lavender , even if I agree with Count Ammercula that Ginny's annoying.
Charlie or Bill Weasley?

[Pardona]

Bill, he's just more my style.

Stocking The Monster Book of Monsters, or The Invisible Book of Invisibility?