Pink Poogle Toy Forum

Why 3 groups? The poisoner could be a OMT. I'm assuming one group is the Dementors and the other is the Death Eaters, (the ones who cast the Avada spell).

I'm including an OMT as an evil group here. So there could even be 4 evil groups.

What? I'm confused. In your original post, you included the poisoner as a "group" and then mentioned OMTs separately. When I suggested that the poisoner could be a OMT and not a group, you then said that a OMT was a group and that there may be 4 evil "groups" that we're up against. But your original statement said there were 3, including OMTs.

Can anyone else see where I'm coming from here?

Yeah, that's my fault. I'm just making estimates on what the innocents are dealing with hear. To clarify, I think there could be 2 evil teams, the dementors then another team, and I also think there could be perhaps 1 or two evil OMT's, which would make 3 or 4 evil groups. I think there could be a couple of neutral players in the game as well.

Ah that clarifys it a bit for me, thanks.

I doubt there'd be 3 groups with 5 people on each team. That's 15 baddies, plus an OMT or two - almost 50% of the game. Typical games have around 30-35% evil players.

ETA: My bad, just read what you meant. Yeah, that sounds to be more correct.

Re; Snape, it's possible that it could be one of those roles where you can choose whether to be Innocent or Evil.

Vote: Fzun
Vote: Angisfab

Two random names from the player's list. I probably won't be able to get back on before execution

Given we have a room system, I think that perhaps the Dementor attacks are room-independent.

However, AK is a short-range attack, so I'm guessing you might have to be in the same room as the attacker. So Ruby, what room were you in last night? Not that we know what room anyone was in, so it won't really help, but still... I'm guessing that the AK-users are a team, and that as long as one of the team is in the same room as someone on their list, that person will be attacked. (at least I think that's how the Wiki said that type of thing would work)

I could see poison being either a room-specific attack (opportunity) or a long-range attack (dill pickles, anyone?).

I'm guessing that Rachel's disappearance was a room effect. I chose the owlery last night, so I would guess she did too, and that's why I was the one who saw the large bird snatch her.

And yes, I realize Ruby was attacked near the owlery, so she might have been in that room; just to set the record straight while I'm away at work, I did NOT attack her. I wonder if it could have been Rachel, or someone else who was in the room and remained secret. On average, there were 4-5 people in each room last night, so there were probably 1-2 others unknown in the owlery.

Still, it's the only clue I have to go on, so I'll
Vote: Rachel

(I'll check after work and change my vote if more experienced players think my logic is completely flawed, or if Ruby was not in the owlery, after all. And the note said Rachel could not vote, but it didn't say she couldn't be voted for, right?)

Okay I think we need Pickles or averly to clear this up. In the last WW game I was in if someone couldn't vote or use their role powers we couldn't vote for them. Is that the case in this game? If so then no one can vote for Rachel tonight.

My guess at the moment is two groups of baddies and a poisoning one man team. I'll wait until later to vote.

Alright, thanks, Pickles.
Unvote: Rachel

Drat, all my hypotheses have been flushed down Moaning Myrtle's toilet. I hope something exciting happens while I'm at work today so I'll have a hint as to how to vote...

Draco too. The poison makes sense with Draco as well because of the whole wine thing. Snape could also be a dreamer using legilimancy, or whatever the role is that gives snippets of roles.

Whoops... I think I made a post up yesterday but never got around to actually posting it...

Alas!
Alas!

I am present.

For all of the folks newer to the game, usually there isn't a lot to go on for the first 2 or 3 days, so we usually just take shots in the dark. Once we start seeing a pattern in attacks or people start trading roles through PM, we get more to go on.

Just noticing one thing - as of the time night was posted yesterday, Pickles stated that she believed that Jas and Rox hadn't opened their roles. That clears them of being the spokesperson for any of the baddies we saw last night. It doesn't clear them of being evil, but we know for sure they're not spokespersons.

I'll definitely be back later on to cast my votes. In the meantime, if anyone would like to role-trade, I am more than happy

Though she said she thought I hadn't opened my role... I had. So erm. Maybe not the greatest thing to go on.