Pink Poogle Toy Forum

Continue your thoughts on American Idol! And how Sanjaya is completely horrible but won't leave the show!

<hr>
Last Thread: http://www.pinkpt.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... f307f508a4

OMG IS THAT BIAS I SMELL!? Tsk tsk!

Haha.

Tonight was... like every other girl's night. No surprises, and everything went as you would have guessed before this week even started.

Yeah... so it sort of takes very little explaining...

Though I did find it funny that Simon forgot Haley's name... I was thinking the EXACT same thing last week or the week before (I forget), while I was in the bathroom during commercial break, about Sabrina. She was the last to perform, and I was like "WHO THE HECK CAN THE LAST PERSON POSSIBLY BE!?", then the commercial break ended and I realized I had forgotten about her completely. I mean she's good, probably in the top in the middle of the pack, but heck, she just didn't stand out to me. (though I remembered her this week. )

I actually didn't think Haley was very bad at all this week. Although, she's probably going to leave along with (hopefully) Antonella.

Sanjaya needs to go home, and the judges need to start seeing how wonderful Chris is. I mean, his last performance was love. I'm SO HAPPY Blake sang a 311 song, too.

The girls are 'meh' for me with the exception of Melinda.

Yes, Sanjaya needs to go but I'm almost positive he won't, he seems to have quite a large fanbase, maybe because he looks like a girl or something? I dunno.

Fidds, do you mean Chris Sligh or Richardson? If you mean Sligh then I agree, and Richardson - eh...

Boys:

Who SHOULD go:
1. Sanjaya (I like him, but he's not even trying anymore)
2. Phil
3. Antonella
4. Haley

Who WILL go
1. Phil
2. Brandon
3. Haley
4. Sabrina? It's kind of hard to tell.

I seriously have no idea who's gonna win. You know how in past seasons it was obvious? Like season 1 with Kelly and season 4 with Carrie... I don't know. I DO think that Melinda and Lakisha will make it to the top 5 and I'd say that a girl will win this year. So far I like Chris Sligh, Gina, and Melinda the most.

In other news, I'm glad that this is last week of the Thursday crap. Even though the shows I watch on Thursdays are on hiatus, three days of Idol seems like too much. Plus, for the next two weeks or so, it'll probably be two hours on Tuesday.

Pffft, Sligh, of course!

MELINDA DOOLITTLE

I'm glad one of the people I supported from the beginning is still good (I'm looking at you Sanjaya- please just sing the song from your audition from now on).

As for who should go for the girls- Antonella and Haley (I agree with Simon about not even knowing her name!).

I think...

Sanjaya and Jared
Haley and Antonella

I'm iffy about Sanjaya, but I REALLY think Antonella has hit a dead end this week. I think everyone else is probably popular enough that she can't catch up (except for maybe Haley).

I LOVE MELINDA DOOLITTLE. ^_^ She is the best ever! I personally think she'll win, if not make it to the final 2. I think Lakisha will have the same fate as Mandisa, perhaps a shocker elimination in the top 12. However, I don't mind if she wins either. Her "My Funny Valentines" performance was so good, not even funny. o.o Each week, her performance sounds like it could have been straight from an album.

Ding dong the Witch is dead!!!! Kinda sad though, I liked how she sang last night :S

Oh well so far all of my favorites have made it through, if Sundance makes it then it's all good.

Whaddacrap?!?! Sabrina?!?! ZOMG. So not fair.

WHAT?!?!?!?!?!?? SANJAYA?!?!?!?!?! OMG.

NO SABRINA NO

Wait. Sanjaya is off American Idol?

PRAISE THE LORD!

No, Sundance is, he won OVER Sundance. That is just. So unfair, goes to show ya, America sometimes does NOT have taste.

Actually... >_>

Tonight's eliminations made me ANGRY!

*smacks every single viewer that votes for Sanjaya*

Tonight was just ridiculous, I would have preferred Antonella stay and Sanjaya go. D:

*goes off an acts angry*

(of course I'm glad Antonella is out... Sanjaya just makes me that angry. >_>)

You and me both, brotha...

Ugh I mean seriously, I think the results are manipulated somehow. There is no way Sanjaya deserved to even make it PAST Hollywood week.