Pink Poogle Toy Forum

God, No.

Mandisa was by far one of the best singers in the competition and one of my favorites. I really can't believe she was voted off this early.

I still love you Mandisa.

I haven't watched it yet (recorded it) but saw who went.

Please tell me how on earth did Mandisa get kicked off and Ace is still there?
Can someone please tell me this?

How can anyone.. ANYONE thing Ace sounds anything but terrible?
He slurs every single thing he sings and sings straight out of his nose.
Now I must've missed the memo.. but since when does THAT sound good coming out of anyone?

I don't think Mandisa would've won it.. but she sure as heck should've stayed longer than freakin Ace.

I'm in majour depression. I only watch the show for four reasons: Elliott, Paris, Mandisa, and to see how wasted Paula can get. Now one of those reasons is gone. I'm really sad. I loved Mandisa.

I really think that the bottom three should have been the top three (except maybe Katharine). Everyone else stinks, in my opinion.

I cant believe Mandisa was gone! ;_; One of my favorites! >_<

The way they had the groups set up, it was pretty obvious. Taylor/Kellie/Chris were the top three, Katherine/Bucky/Ace were the middle three- it could have been random, yeah, but it doesn't seem like it.

Mandisa was a really good singer, but judging by her performance from last night alone, she would have been my second choice for elimination (Ace first. Hearing parts of it over last night was just... ugh... I think that's the worst performance I have ever heard this far in on Idol).

Eh, I actually thought it as going to be Ace, Bucky, and Katherine again.

That night was sad. Not "cry" sad. But "pitiful" sad. The bottom three should have been nothing like that. Ugh, I hate the pity votes people seem to be doing. *cough*Ace*cough*

I hope you're talking about Ace's song. Because if you chose Mandisa's song... I think it was twice as good as Kellie's and Ace's best songs.

I didn't think it was obvious at all. I was actually saying to the TV that the Bottom Three was obviously Ace, Bucky, and Katherine. I would never have guessed the Bottom Three- I actually thought they were the top 3!

No. No. No. No. No.

This can't have happened. This has to be a bad dream or something. -deep breath- I'm going to wake up any minute, go downstairs and watch Idol, and Ace will have been voted off. Yes, that's it.

<.<>.>

GRR.

*dreams*

"Well America, your next American Idol is... ACE!"

*heavy applause*

[/nightmare]

AHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!

i really hope that either Chris or Katherine win.

I'm more upset that BUCKY is still there. And yeah, I didn't think Mandisa would win because she doesn't seem like she has much of a personality but she was definitely one of the best.

Next week's theme: Queen.

I wasn't surprised. A lot of people that liked Mandisa were put off by her preachiness lately. I've never really liked her, she seems really smug to me.

That said, Ace is still really terrible.

I don't really watch American Idol (I'm usually at work) but I LOVED Mandisa. How can she be voted off? That is so stupid; she's one of the most talented singers in the Top 12 -- that just really makes me mad.

At least we have the Wildcard right? Can she come back from that?

They haven't done the wildcard this year or last year. In seasons two and three, people voted their top 10 and wildcards determined the other two. Since there was already a top 12, there's no wildcard .

...

Anyway, as for the theme, Queen, I can SO imagine Ace doing "Bohemian Rhapsody."