It's judgin' time!
And the criteria are...
Does it reflect the team's theme/name?
Does it represent every person on your team?
Is it funny/creative?
Is there a use of pictures taken in the real world?
Would it look good on a T-shirt?
For the B-Sharps:
It gets a 10/10 for reflecting the team name, because it's right on there. That was easy. It gets 8/10 for representing each and every person, because the giant pixelated mushroom, though a nice idea, is kind of hard to see. I like the creative use of the cartoon character to represent Noo, as well as the temple. However, it's not particularly humrous, so it gets 6/10 there. It got an extra point for the Simpsons reference. It uses tons of real world objects in the graphic, which is cool. I especially like the wolf. 9/10. Would it look good on a T-shirt? Maybe. This would look better on a white T-shirt, because of the border. The names wouldn't be very visible, but the details would look nice. 7/10.
For the Cheery Tomatoes:
Again, it gets 10/10 for reflecting the team name. However, for representing each person, it's just not enough to put each person's name on there. 5/10. The giant tomato is very funny, and I like the Neopets item reference, so it gets more points for that. 8/10. Again, the real world graphic is cool, but it doesn't use as many as the blue team's. 6/10. Finally, this would look better blended into a red T-shirt, with the intricate line design and everything. 8/10.
Conclusion: Both graphics are awesome, but only one can win. The B-Sharps got 40 points, and the Cheery Tomatoes got 37. That means the winner is...
We don't know yet. Twist time!!!
I withheld this so far, except for a brief mention: Bonus points. The B-Sharps were the first to be done, so they get 5 bonus points. However, the Cheery Tomatoes were the only ones to actually post the picture on the thread, as per my instructions, so I'll give them 5 bonus points too. The B-Sharps still win. I scared you for a second, though, didn't I? The B-Sharps got 45 point, and the Cheery Tomatoes got 42. That means I'll be adding
8700 points to the pot!
The pot currently stands at 37900 points.
There's one more part to this. The B-Sharps, who won, have to vote on the MVP for this challenge. That person should be the one who did the majority of the work, and will win a special prize. The voting must be done here, and bolded. Think like Werewolf, but only B-Sharps can vote.