Difference between revisions of "Talk:Tyrannian Concert Hall"
DreamingLady (talk | contribs) |
|||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
The article seems to be coming together now, so I think it's only proper to start discussion here then. There has been talk of this before in [[Talk:Blue Kacheek Group]], but should the bands all be on one article, or seperate ones? A redirect must at least be created for all them (and you may notice [[Jub Zambra]] currently has its own article), so what will it be? I'd like to think seperate articles could be made for each of the bands (even if there isn't a lot of information to write about them). Should that idea go through, each one would be linked to each neopet species corresponding to band members, and propably a special category called "Tyrannian Concert Hall" to show their connection to it (and for this article as well I suppose). --[[User:Jacob|Jacob]] 15:32, 28 Aug 2007 (UTC) | The article seems to be coming together now, so I think it's only proper to start discussion here then. There has been talk of this before in [[Talk:Blue Kacheek Group]], but should the bands all be on one article, or seperate ones? A redirect must at least be created for all them (and you may notice [[Jub Zambra]] currently has its own article), so what will it be? I'd like to think seperate articles could be made for each of the bands (even if there isn't a lot of information to write about them). Should that idea go through, each one would be linked to each neopet species corresponding to band members, and propably a special category called "Tyrannian Concert Hall" to show their connection to it (and for this article as well I suppose). --[[User:Jacob|Jacob]] 15:32, 28 Aug 2007 (UTC) | ||
:I'm sure there would just about be enough information for some of the bands to make a nice article, but a summary should remain here... With a ''main article'' link to the band article, I suppose. --[[User:Macbeth|Macbeth]] 11:11, 29 Aug 2007 (UTC) | :I'm sure there would just about be enough information for some of the bands to make a nice article, but a summary should remain here... With a ''main article'' link to the band article, I suppose. --[[User:Macbeth|Macbeth]] 11:11, 29 Aug 2007 (UTC) | ||
They all could have their own article. I think there is just enough information, and would leave enough space to make a concert calendar for this page. However, before this change I'd like to see instrument and music genre info added to all bands, as well as info on who/what their name/they might be/are/is based. As you may have noticed, I've asked for this information in the construction template. I think that info might be just be what some bands need to justify an own article. Also, I'm not looking forward to create fifteen new articles or see them being created, knowing they all are going to have the earlier mentioned construction template. It makes the chances of all of them getting a proper edit smaller. Just my thoughts....[[User:DreamingLady|DreamingLady]] 18:47, 29 Aug 2007 (UTC) | |||
Revision as of 18:47, 29 August 2007
One article vs. separate articles
The article seems to be coming together now, so I think it's only proper to start discussion here then. There has been talk of this before in Talk:Blue Kacheek Group, but should the bands all be on one article, or seperate ones? A redirect must at least be created for all them (and you may notice Jub Zambra currently has its own article), so what will it be? I'd like to think seperate articles could be made for each of the bands (even if there isn't a lot of information to write about them). Should that idea go through, each one would be linked to each neopet species corresponding to band members, and propably a special category called "Tyrannian Concert Hall" to show their connection to it (and for this article as well I suppose). --Jacob 15:32, 28 Aug 2007 (UTC)
- I'm sure there would just about be enough information for some of the bands to make a nice article, but a summary should remain here... With a main article link to the band article, I suppose. --Macbeth 11:11, 29 Aug 2007 (UTC)
They all could have their own article. I think there is just enough information, and would leave enough space to make a concert calendar for this page. However, before this change I'd like to see instrument and music genre info added to all bands, as well as info on who/what their name/they might be/are/is based. As you may have noticed, I've asked for this information in the construction template. I think that info might be just be what some bands need to justify an own article. Also, I'm not looking forward to create fifteen new articles or see them being created, knowing they all are going to have the earlier mentioned construction template. It makes the chances of all of them getting a proper edit smaller. Just my thoughts....DreamingLady 18:47, 29 Aug 2007 (UTC)