Difference between revisions of "Talk:Neodrops"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
==Notability of article?== | ==Notability of article?== | ||
This article takes me by surprise. Should it even be allowed to exist? It has notability in the fact Neodrops were originally similar to M+M's, so it has that going for it. Still, a rewrite in presentation is needed i believe, and I think the proper article name would be the Neodrops one, seeing that is WHAT this information is about, and not a replaced item. Besides, the "Fuzio" was replaced with the [[Kyrii]], and it doesn't have its own article. --[[User:Jacob|Jacob]] 14:29, 9 Jul 2007 (UTC) | This article takes me by surprise. Should it even be allowed to exist? It has notability in the fact Neodrops were originally similar to M+M's, so it has that going for it. Still, a rewrite in presentation is needed i believe, and I think the proper article name would be the Neodrops one, seeing that is WHAT this information is about, and not a replaced item. Besides, the "Fuzio" was replaced with the [[Kyrii]], and it doesn't have its own article. --[[User:Jacob|Jacob]] 14:29, 9 Jul 2007 (UTC) | ||
:Mmm, well, it will have to be wikified and moved to ''Neodrops'' if it is retained. I don't see any reason why we should delete it out of hand - it seems to be much on the line as [[Achyfi]] or [[Juppie]]... a 'collection' of items... I would like to have a few external links confirming the translation information, though, for completeness. --[[User:Macbeth|Macbeth]] 16:25, 9 Jul 2007 (UTC) | :Mmm, well, it will have to be wikified and moved to ''Neodrops'' if it is retained. I don't see any reason why we should delete it out of hand - it seems to be much on the line as [[Achyfi]] or [[Juppie]]... a 'collection' of items... I would like to have a few external links confirming the translation information, though, for completeness. --[[User:Macbeth|Macbeth]] 16:25, 9 Jul 2007 (UTC) | ||
::Then the main article will be "Neodrops", and all data and redirects will be redirected there. :) and in terms of where this information is coming from, this is where Journey to the Lost Isle-er needs to come in, because i have no idea where he/she is getting it. --[[User:Jacob|Jacob]] 20:55, 9 Jul 2007 (UTC) | |||
Latest revision as of 20:55, 9 July 2007
Notability of article?[edit]
This article takes me by surprise. Should it even be allowed to exist? It has notability in the fact Neodrops were originally similar to M+M's, so it has that going for it. Still, a rewrite in presentation is needed i believe, and I think the proper article name would be the Neodrops one, seeing that is WHAT this information is about, and not a replaced item. Besides, the "Fuzio" was replaced with the Kyrii, and it doesn't have its own article. --Jacob 14:29, 9 Jul 2007 (UTC)
- Mmm, well, it will have to be wikified and moved to Neodrops if it is retained. I don't see any reason why we should delete it out of hand - it seems to be much on the line as Achyfi or Juppie... a 'collection' of items... I would like to have a few external links confirming the translation information, though, for completeness. --Macbeth 16:25, 9 Jul 2007 (UTC)
- Then the main article will be "Neodrops", and all data and redirects will be redirected there. :) and in terms of where this information is coming from, this is where Journey to the Lost Isle-er needs to come in, because i have no idea where he/she is getting it. --Jacob 20:55, 9 Jul 2007 (UTC)