Difference between revisions of "Talk:Hannah and the Ice Caves (game)"
m (moved Talk:Hannah and the Ice Caves to Talk:Hannah and the Ice Caves (game): although the game came first, I think the plot trumps this in terms of world importance if nothing else.) |
|||
| (3 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown) | |||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
:No, it isn't unnessesary, because one may be searching for the plot or the game of the same title. And lets not forget that the plot came first, then the game, so if any article deserves to have the plain title "Hannah and the Ice Caves", it's the plot article, and this to be named "Hannah and the Ice Caves (Game)". --[[User:Jacob|Jacob]] 12:50, 6 Dec 2006 (CST) | :No, it isn't unnessesary, because one may be searching for the plot or the game of the same title. And lets not forget that the plot came first, then the game, so if any article deserves to have the plain title "Hannah and the Ice Caves", it's the plot article, and this to be named "Hannah and the Ice Caves (Game)". --[[User:Jacob|Jacob]] 12:50, 6 Dec 2006 (CST) | ||
It is unnecessary because only articles ''A'' and ''B'' exist, and ''A'' links to ''B'' as ''B'' links to ''A''. On wikipedia, for example, you do not see disambiguation pages with only two articles... --[[User:Macbeth|Macbeth]] 12:41, 7 Dec 2006 (CST) | It is unnecessary because only articles ''A'' and ''B'' exist, and ''A'' links to ''B'' as ''B'' links to ''A''. On wikipedia, for example, you do not see disambiguation pages with only two articles... --[[User:Macbeth|Macbeth]] 12:41, 7 Dec 2006 (CST) | ||
:Not everyone here at the NeoDex knows how to fully use it, and i think it's better to show all the articles possible that they may be searching for rather than have them work it out on their own. It's being helpful, the disambiguation page is, to new and future users. At least that was my intention on creating it. --[[User:Jacob|Jacob]] 14:36, 7 Dec 2006 (CST) | |||
But there are only two articles that it could be, and at the top of one, it links to the other in case one is searching for it. Note how on Wikipedia when there are only two meanings of a term they stick to this procedure... --[[User:Macbeth|Macbeth]] 17:01, 7 Dec 2006 (CST) | |||
Latest revision as of 23:32, 20 January 2011
Title[edit]
As this page is titled "[...] (Game)", this is included in the game name with the template. Propose moving this to "Hannah and the Ice Caves" (there is a disamb. there at the moment) and maintain "Hannah and the Ice Caves (Plot)"? The disambiguation seems unnecessary for two results, anyway... --Macbeth 11:41, 6 Dec 2006 (CST)
- No, it isn't unnessesary, because one may be searching for the plot or the game of the same title. And lets not forget that the plot came first, then the game, so if any article deserves to have the plain title "Hannah and the Ice Caves", it's the plot article, and this to be named "Hannah and the Ice Caves (Game)". --Jacob 12:50, 6 Dec 2006 (CST)
It is unnecessary because only articles A and B exist, and A links to B as B links to A. On wikipedia, for example, you do not see disambiguation pages with only two articles... --Macbeth 12:41, 7 Dec 2006 (CST)
- Not everyone here at the NeoDex knows how to fully use it, and i think it's better to show all the articles possible that they may be searching for rather than have them work it out on their own. It's being helpful, the disambiguation page is, to new and future users. At least that was my intention on creating it. --Jacob 14:36, 7 Dec 2006 (CST)
But there are only two articles that it could be, and at the top of one, it links to the other in case one is searching for it. Note how on Wikipedia when there are only two meanings of a term they stick to this procedure... --Macbeth 17:01, 7 Dec 2006 (CST)