Fantasia Barrino or Diana DeGarmo?

[Mark]

I heard them both sing the song 'I Believe' and I definately like Fantasia better. I cannot stand Diana's voice; Fantasia deserves the AI3 Winner title.

Boooooooo. DIANA DEGARMO WAS ROBBED!!!!!!

Down with the Ferocious Burrito!

[Fiddelysquat]

I vote for a swift death.

[paola]

I haven't hear either of them sing, so neither.

[+Phantom-]

Diana.
Fanatasia sounds like a diseased cat being hit by a car and then kicked several times, IMO. o_0

[Alex]

Neither. I don't care particuarly for either of them.

[Medusa]

I liked La Toya London and George Huff. I suppose if I had to choose between the two in the Poll though I'd choose Diana DeGarmo, no real reasoning behind it except she seemed like a nice girl...

[Kitten Medli]

I liked La Toya London and George Huff. I suppose if I had to choose between the two in the Poll though I'd choose Diana DeGarmo, no real reasoning behind it except she seemed like a nice girl...

*high five* Huff Nation power!

[Lass]

I hate both of them.

Three seasons of American Idol is too many.

[DM was on fire!]

I didn't know Fantasia Barrino did Dreams...*checks AI transcript on WNDM* Wow, she did. Diana's version is better. Fantasia added too many 'yeahs'.

[Mark]

I didn't know Fantasia Barrino did Dreams...*checks AI transcript on WNDM* Wow, she did. Diana's version is better. Fantasia added too many 'yeahs'.

I'm in your siggy!! Haha! Awesome!

I agree. Fantasia needs to tone down the 'yeahs'

[DM was on fire!]

I didn't know Fantasia Barrino did Dreams...*checks AI transcript on WNDM* Wow, she did. Diana's version is better. Fantasia added too many 'yeahs'.

I'm in your siggy!! Haha! Awesome!

I agree. Fantasia needs to tone down the 'yeahs'

I loved the fericious burrito thing. As I said one time to myself, Fantasia added more 'yeahs' to I Believe then there are in Usher's song 'Yeah'.

[Christopher]

I'm not sure whether it was cancelled but the season with either off these two 'people' hasn't shown up.

[Rissa]

I don't see where you people come up with this whole "duck filled with helium" thing. I personally love Fantasia. Diana is a wonderful singer, I must admit, but she sounds too much like too many other people that I have heard singing. Fantasia's voice is rich and her style is classy and original, and I love that. Diana doesn't want to make me stand up and sing and dance. Fantasia does. Her songs seem to have so much more spirit in them, as if they were made up by Fantasia herself, not as if they were just something she picked because she liked the sound of them.

Maybe I should make a Fantasia set just to spite all of you Diana-lovers.

[Kitten Medli]

I don't see where you people come up with this whole "duck filled with helium" thing. I personally love Fantasia. Diana is a wonderful singer, I must admit, but she sounds too much like too many other people that I have heard singing. Fantasia's voice is rich and her style is classy and original, and I love that. Diana doesn't want to make me stand up and sing and dance. Fantasia does. Her songs seem to have so much more spirit in them, as if they were made up by Fantasia herself, not as if they were just something she picked because she liked the sound of them.

Maybe I should make a Fantasia set just to spite all of you Diana-lovers.

I dont agree about Fantasia,but I do agree people need to be more respectful and drop the duck thing. I keep those kind of comments to myself.

I will also agree Diana isnt the most unique tool in the shed,but I believe she is very talented.

I WISH it was cancelled,now..oh,if only Christopher..

[Bangel]

I dont agree about Fantasia,but I do agree people need to be more respectful and drop the duck thing. I keep those kind of comments to myself.

You asked for opinions. And my opinion about Fantasia IS the duck thing.