SHHH!!! Can you read? Want to prove it? Meet fellow book worms and discuss the literary brilliance of Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone.
Topic locked

Fri Jul 15, 2005 9:45 pm

Josephine wrote:ROLL ON TOMORROW.

Because I'm an uber nerd, are we going to keep using this thread after we've all read it? Or do a new one with a big spoiler warning on it, like the one we had when OoTP came out?


I have no idea. Maybe it needs a split though. I'd suggest a new thread for those who have read it and let those who haven't continue specualting here.

(Sorry for ignoring you hun! :hug: )

Fri Jul 15, 2005 9:46 pm

Josephine wrote:ROLL ON TOMORROW.

Because I'm an uber nerd, are we going to keep using this thread after we've all read it? Or do a new one with a big spoiler warning on it, like the one we had when OoTP came out?


I suppose we can have another thread with a big spoiler warning in it. I mean, this thread is basically us just all wondering what's going to happen in the book, it'd be pretty pointless after we read it.

Fri Jul 15, 2005 9:48 pm

Waaaahhh!!! I can't wait!!!!
I'm horribly worried about who's going to die though... :(
It's going to be a looong drive back home after I get my book. Especially since it's already a long drive in the first place. Almost two hours. o_o;
...I just know I'm going to be crying like crazy in this book. :(
And I keep going the "what if it's ______?" path.
Oh, what an upwelling of dread it is that fills my heart!
What if it's Remus?? T__T

Well, I think I'm going to go take a nap so I can stay up all night reading. :P

Fri Jul 15, 2005 9:55 pm

Stupid me still thinks Hagrid is the HBP. ;P

Fri Jul 15, 2005 10:01 pm

I'm thinking it's Snape.
Snape wasn't on the Black family tree so I'm guessing he wasn't a pureblood.
Plus it could be why he wasn't much friends with the Slytherins, and why he joined Voldemort so he got some acceptance.
Also could be why he bounced on over to be a spy for Dumbledore, because he felt fairly hypocritical.
I've had far too much time to think about this.

Fri Jul 15, 2005 10:19 pm

o_0 wrote:Stupid me still thinks Hagrid is the HBP. ;P


Haha, don't worry, me too. But if it's a new character....ah I don't know, I think I've run out of conspiracy theories. .__.

Fri Jul 15, 2005 10:20 pm

Shoelace wrote:I'm thinking it's Snape.
Snape wasn't on the Black family tree so I'm guessing he wasn't a pureblood.
Plus it could be why he wasn't much friends with the Slytherins, and why he joined Voldemort so he got some acceptance.
Also could be why he bounced on over to be a spy for Dumbledore, because he felt fairly hypocritical.
I've had far too much time to think about this.


He always could have been burned off the list due to his leaving of the Death Eaters. :P

EDIT: Yes. :P Because just because someone's a Half-Blood doesn't mean they have to be half-wizard, half-human. They can be half-giant. o.o

Fri Jul 15, 2005 10:27 pm

o_0 wrote:
Shoelace wrote:I'm thinking it's Snape.
Snape wasn't on the Black family tree so I'm guessing he wasn't a pureblood.
Plus it could be why he wasn't much friends with the Slytherins, and why he joined Voldemort so he got some acceptance.
Also could be why he bounced on over to be a spy for Dumbledore, because he felt fairly hypocritical.
I've had far too much time to think about this.


He always could have been burned off the list due to his leaving of the Death Eaters. :P

EDIT: Yes. :P Because just because someone's a Half-Blood doesn't mean they have to be half-wizard, half-human. They can be half-giant. o.o

I thought Snape was still a spy o_O

Fri Jul 15, 2005 10:58 pm

Shoelace wrote:
o_0 wrote:
Shoelace wrote:I'm thinking it's Snape.
Snape wasn't on the Black family tree so I'm guessing he wasn't a pureblood.
Plus it could be why he wasn't much friends with the Slytherins, and why he joined Voldemort so he got some acceptance.
Also could be why he bounced on over to be a spy for Dumbledore, because he felt fairly hypocritical.
I've had far too much time to think about this.


He always could have been burned off the list due to his leaving of the Death Eaters. :P

EDIT: Yes. :P Because just because someone's a Half-Blood doesn't mean they have to be half-wizard, half-human. They can be half-giant. o.o

I thought Snape was still a spy o_O


Snape not being on the Black Family tree doesn't mean he's not a pureblood, it just means he isn't related to Sirius. The tree doesn't contain every pureblood in existence, just the ones related to the Black family
And, as already stated, the Half Blood Prince is a new character. As stated by Rowling herself, in fact.
Sorry, but I'm just getting sick of conspiracies and bad fanfics. (and I'm sick of the conspiracies because of bad fanfics that win contests in the newspaper in fact, where the people don't even seem to have read the books. So again, sorry.)

Fri Jul 15, 2005 11:12 pm

Alright then *sighs sadly*.
Anyone in the UK watch the castle thing?!?
JK read an extract from the book!!! *squees*
I'm far to excited to sleep now.
EDIT: Sirius says the purebloods are all related.
page 105 in OoTP (in the UK edition)
Harry: "You're related to the Malfoys!"
Sirius: " The pure-blood families are all interrelated," said Sirius. "If you're only going to let your sons or daughters marry pure-bloods your choice is very limited; there are hardly any of us left."
Harry may not have seen Snape, but I doubt Harry would have missed it if he was there, though it could be a reason Sirius was so nasty to him if Snape was his distant cousin or something.
Last edited by Shoelace on Fri Jul 15, 2005 11:19 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Fri Jul 15, 2005 11:18 pm

Me too. Did you think that Fred and George seemed a bit cold to Ron in that chapter? Or was it the way JKR read it?

Fri Jul 15, 2005 11:20 pm

ShyShy wrote:Me too. Did you think that Fred and George seemed a bit cold to Ron in that chapter? Or was it the way JKR read it?

Could just be the way she read it.
What about that last sentence? :roll:

Fri Jul 15, 2005 11:21 pm

Yeah, either a trap or... DUN DUN DUN!! Draco's gone good. Or maybe he lost his daddy. :roflol:

Fri Jul 15, 2005 11:22 pm

ShyShy wrote:Yeah, either a trap or... DUN DUN DUN!! Draco's gone good. Or maybe he lost his daddy. :roflol:

I hope the trio don't go out and confront him or something. Perhaps someone is chasing him! Like, a rabid dog... or Lupin.
EDIT: His dad is in prison, isn't he?

Fri Jul 15, 2005 11:23 pm

That rabid dog comment made me think of Sirius :(. I hope it's Lupin on a full moon, DIE MALFOY!!

EDIT: Maybe he, uhh, okay, you got me.
Topic locked