Pink Poogle Toy Forum

Brooke?! NO! NOOO!!!!

Syesha?! NO! NOOO!!!!

</copycatness>

I say the irish woman will win american Idol. Go Carly.
David go home plzkthnx

1. Hell yes.
2. HELL yes.

Which David? Cause if you're suggesting that Archuletta kid, I agree. David Cook is my fave

Well, I was talking about Archuletta, dunno about 3lla...

i was talking about BOTH of the Davids.
David Archuleta irks me. He just seems like hes wayyyyyy too nice. David Cook on the other hand seems wayyyyyy to smug and pretty up himself. I dunno what it is but its Cook's facial expression all the time which has sorta done that for me.

Brooke would be successful after the competition anyway, but Carly should so win. I'd laugh and go "An Irish woman won american idol! Neerner-neerner-neerner!!"

I used to complain about foreign people being on American Idol.
Funny thing is, Carly, the Irish one is one of my favorites.
hahah.

I like David A. He's a bit boring and Disneyish but he has the best voice.

I think this is what will happen:

1. David A
2. David C
3. Carly
4. Brooke
5. Jason
6. Syesha

You could probably switch 3 & 4 but I think that either Jason or Syesha will go next.

I like all of the remaining contestants, but I think that Michael should be #4 or #5. He was definitely better than Jason and Syesha.

Edit on April 23: Wow, you lose again America

SRSLY.
My lord, who was stupid enough to keep someone stupid enough to start over in the middle of a song? I mean...has Carly not watched the other Idols? She should know that you just roll right along like nothing happened. YOU DON'T FREAKING RESTART THE SONG.

I understand why Brooke started over again, but she did mess up big time. And Jason's performance was really poor as well. The wrong person went home, but, then again, this is the same America that voted Taylor Hicks a winner, so I don't expect my favorite to win...

BAD DM. Carly was just peachy if you ask me.

Oh yeah, I did actually watch this week, much to my dismay.

I don't know who you were watching but I didn't see Carly restart in the middle of a song... Brooke restarted.

Wrong person went home in my humble opinion. But ah well. I lost faith in American Idol after Taylor Hicks.

ARGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG.
I was sooo aggravated. Brooke should have totally gone home. That's the second time she's stopped and restarted, and she never shuts up on the elimination nights. She just makes me mad. I used to like her but she's gone downhill. They told us even in middle school dont let people know if you mess up.

And then being sick i couldnt even yell at the tv like I wanted to. America can seriously get things wrong.

brooke seriously should have gone home.
I do not accept this stop and start whenever you like.

David Cook has totally ruined The Phantom of the Opera for me now. I hate him for that. David Archuleta completely butchered Think of Me.
I never ever want Idol to do Andrew Lloyd Webber songs again.

And as for Carly, sad to say but she was drowned out when she sang Jesus Christ Superstar. But compared to Brooke she did loads better