Moogie
I love the color scheme of this set. The image you chose isn't very good at all, and I see that you've done your best with it. However, the little pixel brush thingies that are scattered around the signature dont seem to go very well with everything else. I also dont think they should be 'in front' of the person in the image. Perhaps some other shape, with a more "anti alias" feel to it would work better. However, in all, the sig has a very nice feel to it. - 8.5/10
stinkyllama
I kind of prefer the old colors of the image. Perhaps it's just me. Also, I really dislike the random things you've put in the background. They dont go with the set at all. You also could have chosen a better font for the signature. The "sparkle sparkle sparkle" text is especially irritating. I dont think what you have done with the main text, worked very well here. There's a stroke but no fill. Perhaps it's just me, but it really irks me. - 6/10
kiay
I like your graphics, but for some reason, I dont like this set very much. I love the colors, and the background. But the pixel texture annoys me. I dont mind the vertical scanlines, I think they go well with the signature, but there are occasionally white dots that look like a 75 pixel dither or something. Those really go against the soft feeling of the signature. There's a bar that says "dehue" on the right that looks out of place, too. Also, I really dont like the font you chose for the set. I liked a lot of your other graphics much better. =\ - 7/10
Iath-em
This isn't the best of what I've seen of your graphics. But I absolutly love the color scheme. The abstractness of the signature is very nice. However, I do wish that you could tone down, or get rid of the scanlines all-together, as they seem to really disrupt the flow of the signature. I like how you did your text, and I'm not going to bug you about how it's not very legible, it looks very nice this way. I like the border you did for this set, also. - 9/10
Neko
I really like the soft feel of the set. It's very pretty. The avatar, I love. But the signature, on the right side, is a little empty. I think you could have also done a little more with the border you had to make the signature more interesting. Although, the colors of the signature is very nice. - 8.5/10
Good luck to you all!
|