Sun Jul 11, 2004 11:42 pm
Yeah I cant believe they dont have peeves in it.
Sun Jul 11, 2004 11:50 pm
...Alex wrote:Maybe Petunia's a squib
No, she isn't. Her parents were muggles and a squib is a person with magical parents but no powers.
Mon Jul 12, 2004 2:44 am
Sapphire Faerie wrote:Target Practise wrote:Christopher wrote:I hope the movie cutouts aren't affecting the newer books...that could mean Peeves could have had a major role to play but has been edited out since WB has something against him.
yeah I was wondering why there was no Peeves. He was always a funny character to me, and I was looking forward to seeing him...
If he's not in the fifth film I'll scream. I have got to see him chasing Umbridge with McGonagall's walking stick.
I know! And the part where Fred and George tell him to take care of Umbridge or whatever they said... I mean, no one else can fit the job...
Mon Jul 12, 2004 3:14 am
Twizzler0171 wrote:Sapphire Faerie wrote:Target Practise wrote:Christopher wrote:I hope the movie cutouts aren't affecting the newer books...that could mean Peeves could have had a major role to play but has been edited out since WB has something against him.
yeah I was wondering why there was no Peeves. He was always a funny character to me, and I was looking forward to seeing him...
If he's not in the fifth film I'll scream. I have got to see him chasing Umbridge with McGonagall's walking stick.
I know! And the part where Fred and George tell him to take care of Umbridge or whatever they said... I mean, no one else can fit the job...
If they just stick him in movie 4 or 5, it'll confuse the heck out of the people who haven't read the books. Pity.
I really want to at least see Peeves in movie 5. He was hilarious driving Umbridge crazy.
Mon Jul 12, 2004 3:44 am
I think that the theory of Hagrid being the Prince is better than the Dudley theory. Hagrid is half giant. He very well could be heir to the leading position of a large group of giants. Dumbledore obviously thought that the giants were important to the war against Voldemort. Perhaps Hagrid will play a large role in winning over the giants' alliegance.
I'm also thinking the Prince might be Firenze or one of the centaurs. They are considered "half breeds" by the Ministry, aren't they? And centaurs aren't exactly push-overs. They want basic rights, and if the Ministry gives them those rights, they may be able to help defeat Voldemort.
I'm also thinking the Prince might be Firenze or one of the centaurs. They are considered "half breeds" by the Ministry, aren't they? And centaurs aren't exactly push-overs. They want basic rights, and if the Ministry gives them those rights, they may be able to help defeat Voldemort.
Mon Jul 12, 2004 6:52 am
I want to see more of Tonks and Kreacher. This reminds me of something I read on MuggleNet; if Harry inherits Sirius's house and belongings, shouldn't Kreacher belong to him too?
Mon Jul 12, 2004 7:37 am
Jo wrote:I want to see more of Tonks and Kreacher. This reminds me of something I read on MuggleNet; if Harry inherits Sirius's house and belongings, shouldn't Kreacher belong to him too?
I agree. It doesn't make sense!
Mon Jul 12, 2004 11:47 pm
Dawn2 wrote:...Alex wrote:Maybe Petunia's a squib
No, she isn't. Her parents were muggles and a squib is a person with magical parents but no powers.
I know what a squib is. I also know that JKR's never said if Lily and Petunia's parents were muggles. Their parents were 'excited' and 'proud' to have a witch in their family. Obviously, that means they are muggles. It could also mean her parents were both squibs. Wouldn't you be proud if one of your children had magical blood, defying all odds?
Why did Petunia know about Dementors? Sure, she overheard James talking about them, but wouldn't she have forgotten something like that over the years? Or forced herself to forget, seeing how much she hates magic?
I don't really think Petunia's a squib, which is why I said 'maybe'. She could be. She probably isn't, but she could be.
Sapphire Faerie wrote:J.K. Rowling works with Steven Kloves when he writes the screenplays, she advises him on what should stay because it'll be important in later books.
They worked together on the first two screenplays. In the third, she was extremely busy (with OotP, probably, and her pregnancy), so he only asked her on a few changes he made, which is why PoA's so different from the first two films.
Tue Jul 13, 2004 2:10 am
Dumbledore could be the prince! Hagrid cant be because there is only one person in his family that can be kin to Grodric and that would be his father(whats the odds of that?). I know its not his mother.
BTW: last poster you must not know what one is because you cant be a squib with muggle parents.
BTW: last poster you must not know what one is because you cant be a squib with muggle parents.
Tue Jul 13, 2004 3:25 am
sirius died because he fell through the veil of wasitcalled (its an old myth, a veil that seperates life and death, used all over the place, transformers included) the whispers were of people whom have died, probably trying to get through.
but he'll be back, prior incantartum and the likes.
but he'll be back, prior incantartum and the likes.
Tue Jul 13, 2004 3:33 am
Who was that pointed at?
Tue Jul 13, 2004 3:34 am
Jo wrote:I want to see more of Tonks and Kreacher. This reminds me of something I read on MuggleNet; if Harry inherits Sirius's house and belongings, shouldn't Kreacher belong to him too?
I dont think he would get Kreacher, because he is Bound to the "family". Harry isnt blood and thats what it goes by in magic world.
Tue Jul 13, 2004 4:33 am
I think that the theory of Hagrid being the Prince is better than the Dudley theory. Hagrid is half giant. He very well could be heir to the leading position of a large group of giants. Dumbledore obviously thought that the giants were important to the war against Voldemort. Perhaps Hagrid will play a large role in winning over the giants' alliegance.
I'm also thinking the Prince might be Firenze or one of the centaurs. They are considered "half breeds" by the Ministry, aren't they? And centaurs aren't exactly push-overs. They want basic rights, and if the Ministry gives them those rights, they may be able to help defeat Voldemort.
I would go for the obvious. Voldemort is a half blood and something along the lines of the prince of darkness though Hagrid being a prince would be pretty cool except that in the 5th book you see that giants have a leader who is just big and ugly and gets killed off sometimes. -.0
Tue Jul 13, 2004 4:37 am
\Temiko wrote:I think that the theory of Hagrid being the Prince is better than the Dudley theory. Hagrid is half giant. He very well could be heir to the leading position of a large group of giants. Dumbledore obviously thought that the giants were important to the war against Voldemort. Perhaps Hagrid will play a large role in winning over the giants' alliegance.
I'm also thinking the Prince might be Firenze or one of the centaurs. They are considered "half breeds" by the Ministry, aren't they? And centaurs aren't exactly push-overs. They want basic rights, and if the Ministry gives them those rights, they may be able to help defeat Voldemort.
I would go for the obvious. Voldemort is a half blood and something along the lines of the prince of darkness though Hagrid being a prince would be pretty cool except that in the 5th book you see that giants have a leader who is just big and ugly and gets killed off sometimes. -.0
I heard that the writer said it was NOT Harry or Voldemort.
Tue Jul 13, 2004 6:52 am
xaviersxmen wrote:Jo wrote:I want to see more of Tonks and Kreacher. This reminds me of something I read on MuggleNet; if Harry inherits Sirius's house and belongings, shouldn't Kreacher belong to him too?
I dont think he would get Kreacher, because he is Bound to the "family". Harry isnt blood and thats what it goes by in magic world.
Who WOULD he go to then? The Malfoys? The Weasleys? (all pure bloods are connected)