American Idol 05 (Split)

WIS · **Posted:** Wed Apr 13, 2005 4:02 am

bluebubblegirl wrote:

I really hope Nadia is not kicked off, she is talented, she just needs to egt it together and pick appropriate songs. vonzell was good, Scott sucked. i think Anthony and Anwar improved. Carrie was terrible and missed an entire note at the end which lasted about 5 seconds and I am officially deaf now. i caanot stand it when people try to hit a note, and they fail miserably, thinking that they nailed it.

Anyways, the only person that really deserved to go is Scott this week.
i dont even remmeber what his song was like, I just remember that it was crap, and he was rude to the judges. if the judges don't like you, you have to just suck it up, and get over it.

btw, although constantine did sound good, it sounded more karaoke to me, because he didnt bring himself in to the song, it sounded like he was imitationg freddie mercury. Just not very original. As for Bo Bice, i can't even remember what he sang, because it was that boring.

Good job Vonzell. She was never my favorite, but she proved herself as a great singer today.

Anthony missed that last note last week, bleh. But I think he did a decent job, if he survived being in the bottom three last week, he'll probably not be in the bottom three this week.

Predictions:
Scott
Nadia
Bo

Anyone else think that Carrey looked just a bit like Avril when she was performing?

Shollia · **Posts:** 1269 **Joined:** Tue Jun 01, 2004 4:22 am

Carrey keeps reminding me of Kelly Clarkson when she performs. *shrugs*

livin_in_the_shadow · **Posted:** Wed Apr 13, 2005 10:50 am

Shollia wrote:

Carrey keeps reminding me of Kelly Clarkson when she performs. *shrugs*

watericesage wrote:

Anyone else think that Carrey looked just a bit like Avril when she was performing?

I think she had a lot of eye makeup like eyeliner on because her eyes were really dark

bluebubblegirl · **Posted:** Thu Apr 14, 2005 2:55 am

I connot beleive it, this week was an outrage. Nadia??? Nadia??? what???

I am very upset, every week Scoot dissapoints me, and Nadia show how unique and creative she is. Even Simon gives her good feedback. This is true injustice. And although i don't like Bo, i think its sad he ended up in the bottom 3, he does have a good voice.

WIS · **Posted:** Thu Apr 14, 2005 5:01 am

Well, I was right about the bottom three, but I was EXTREMELY surprised when Scott was safe, leaving Bo and Nadia.

Scott wasn't good last week, Nadia and Bo were both better than him (that week). (In my opinion anyways)

Shollia · **Posts:** 1269 **Joined:** Tue Jun 01, 2004 4:22 am

So... Nadia was kicked off tonight? (haven't watched it yet.. recorded it)
Meh.. not surprising since she's been in the bottom 3 for a while now.
I really hope Scott is gone next week though... he's getting on my nerves. Well actually I hope Constantine goes next week, but since I know that's not going to happen......... :roll:

Adam loves Hilary Duff · **Posted:** Thu Apr 14, 2005 2:16 pm

Shollia wrote:

So... Nadia was kicked off tonight? (haven't watched it yet.. recorded it)
Meh.. not surprising since she's been in the bottom 3 for a while now.
I really hope Scott is gone next week though... he's getting on my nerves. Well actually I hope Constantine goes next week, but since I know that's not going to happen......... :roll:

Bo better go before the top 3.
I dun wanna owe my dad money.
Nadia is talented, but she doesn't use songs to exactly show off her talent.
I do hope she gets a recording contract.

atomicblonde · **Posted:** Thu Apr 14, 2005 3:37 pm

I've wanted Scott off since he auditioned, he better go next week.

I

ed Constantine this week. He and Anthony are still my faves.

Sterl · **Posted:** Thu Apr 14, 2005 4:48 pm

Hmm out of those three I think Nadia deserved to go. She's talented but I think she's the weakest vocalist out of all of them. I actually like Scott, while he's not one of my favorites I still think he has a nice smooth voice. I think he did a good job on that Hall and Oates song *well except for the rough beginning*.

Constantine though is my absolute favorite. My prediction for the final 2 is Constantine and Carrie. Who knows though ..

Ammer · **Posted:** Thu Apr 14, 2005 8:32 pm

Predictable. Nadia was bound to leave sooner or later. She has a wonderful voice but chooses the wrong songs to show it. Sad, really.

Scott better go. He should get out based on his past (Yes, Shollia, his past) and his attitude. His voice may be nice but I know for a fact he won't be successful in the industry. How many people from American Idol have actually made it big in the industry besides Kelly Clarkson and Clay Aiken?

bluebubblegirl · **Posted:** Fri Apr 15, 2005 2:35 am

Who even votes for Scott? It must be sympathy votes, I don't know anyone that would evr even concider voting for him.

Shollia · **Posts:** 1269 **Joined:** Tue Jun 01, 2004 4:22 am

Ammer wrote:

Scott better go. He should get out based on his past (Yes, Shollia, his past) and his attitude.

Why did you point me out :roll:

As I've said before... I could really care less if he was arrested before for the small thing that happened, BUT if they have kicked out other people because of an arrest they should've done so with him as well.

Ammer · **Posted:** Fri Apr 15, 2005 7:19 pm

Shollia wrote:

Ammer wrote:

Scott better go. He should get out based on his past (Yes, Shollia, his past) and his attitude.

Why did you point me out :roll:

As I've said before... I could really care less if he was arrested before for the small thing that happened, BUT if they have kicked out other people because of an arrest they should've done so with him as well.

I pointed you out because you seemed to be against it. That the media was blowing it out of proportion when they were simply re-telling the police report.

bluebubblegirl · **Posted:** Wed Apr 20, 2005 1:27 am

Vonzell rocked tonight!!!
Carrie was the worst!

I stil hope Scott goes.

Pokemon Kid · **Posted:** Wed Apr 20, 2005 1:36 am

Constantine: Wow, just wow, he was one of the best that night.
Vonzell: She just amazed me, her voice reminds me of Latoya.
Bo: My favourite!
Anwar: MUCH MUCH better from his other preformances.
Carrie: Nah, I didn't like her. She screwed up.
Scott: He screwed up, too.
Anthony: GO FEDEROV!

I personally think Carrie Underwood is going tomorrow.

And Paula was annoying tonight. She kept embarrising herself.

Pink Poogle Toy Forum

American Idol 05 (Split)

Who is online