Pink Poogle Toy Forum

I loved the book, though the ending was a bit iffy for me. I don't consider it one of the greatest books I've ever read. It's just good. She's also the author of Number the Stars, which great as well. I read that in sixth grade. Lowry really is an amazing author. And she wrote all her books in Massachusetts XD

I liked The Giver...but I thought the ending was sad. Not sad as in written badly, but sad as in it made me feel sad. I've read Gathering Blue too, good book also, same thing with the ending.

Btw, Gathering Blue is not a sequel to the Giver. Like Starchaser said, "it's set in a different place/time with different characters."

Also, there was this kid in my first through fourth grade classes, and he said that Lois Lowry was his step-grandmother. I don't know if I'm supposed to believe that...

I just like to know what happens to the characters after all the excitement's over.

For all I know they could have went and frozen to death

I think they made it. I find the ending kinda optimistic.

I had to read that book in 4th grade for a book report. Dear God I hated it. I'll never read it again.

I read this book back in school. I thought the start and finish was real boring but I liked the middle parts.

I've never read this book, but my brother would like to say that he found it absolutely horrendous.

I read it in grade 8. And I totally forget how it ends. So, no comment on the ending, but the book was kind of strange. But it was good enough to read again, I just thought it had wierd ideas.

I read the messager, which is the last book of them. It brings characters from The Giver and Gathering Blue together. Jonas becomes leader of where he landed now called "Village."

It's such a fantastic book. I'm afraid of going running by myself in the woods sometimes because of it.

I loved it! My sister had to read it for a book report, and i had nothing else to read, so i read it... I've read it three times so far, i've just read it for the third last month. about the ending -> (written in small white font so you can skip over it if you want )
i think it's sad. He died, didn't he? Think about it. It was freezing, the baby was all weak and stuff, and then suddenly he gets this burst of energy and goes over the hill, to the WONDERFUL town where colour and songs abound. maybe the point is he came to our world when he died. Maybe he didn't die at all, but i always thought all the villages had no colour and all that.. i know it wasn't just his village that lived like that. *shrugs* i have no idea, really. I think it's the kind of thing where everyone thinks something different. it did seem to lack a lot of the.. awesomeness that was in the other parts, it seemed like she had runout of ideas and was just throwing something together.)

*Gasps*

I didn't notice that! Ooooh. This makes everything a great deal more interesting. o_o

(I wonder what happened to Gabe...)

I thought the ending was supposed to be pessimistic! o.O

I've read it. It wasn't hard to read as the language is pretty simple. The concept was nice. It was interesting to realise what these people really do and see, which was a nice discovery. However, it's not really one of those books I'd like to read over and over again. I know what's going to happen now, which was my original interest in the book.

Gabe was mentioned in the Messenger as either a playful 8-year-old kid or an energitic one or something like that. If I had the book with me, I'd quote it, but I already returned it to the library.

I loved all three of the books. They made you think and make connections. My 7th grade english class had lots of great discussions when we read it as a class, though half the class (including me) already read it before. My favorite was The Messenger, since it connected the The Giver and Gathering Blue. Lois Lowry truly is a wonderful author.

I read it last year for school. I loved it! We were supposed the read chapter 1 the first night we got it, I read the whole book! I haven't read any sequels or anything, I really just liked the philosophical ideas. I like books that make you think (The Giver, Farenheit 451, The House of the Scorpion < good books)