Igg wrote:
skizzy the wonder lizard wrote:
Igg wrote:
Likewise you might want to read a story-fied version of Hamlet as opposed to the play.
don't do this. never do this with any play. if you do not know how to read shakespeare, i strongly suggest you learn how by practicing and using study guides rather than getting adapted versions. you are seriously cheating yourself (and insulting the author, in my opinion) by reading adaptations.
Wow, thankyou. It's a shame I can't punish you for insulting my intelligence, really.
I have read the play. I read plays. I ALSO read story versions. I know how to read shakespeare and I don't need your suggestions with study guides. I resent being patronised, a little bit.
However, there is absolutely nothing wrong with reading an adaption of a play in this context. This context suggests you need an overview of the story, not a detailed working knowledge of the play.
If this list was to do with reading in play-form, why Hamlet? It could have suggested many Shakespeare plays- indeed all of them.
It's a good introduction to Shakespeare to read the story and then the play, too. Reading a play straight off is chucking yourself in at the deep end and perhaps unwise, and daunting.
wow, good to know that the first thing you think of when someone says something you don't agree with is to punish them. very becoming for a mod.
there is everything wrong with reading a story version of a play in this context. wanting to be well-read before one goes to college does not mean just knowing the
stories. becoming well-read, especially before college, means learnign how to
read read, that is, being able to get as much out of a text as possible. it includes picking up nuances in the lines. it includes learning to make decisons about the characters for oneself based on what the AUTHOR gives you, not spoon-fed to you (sometimes in a very one-sided fashion) by a summary. hamlet in particular, as there is all that discussion about hamlet's madness. you can't have a proper discussion without reading the play itself, analysing the lines that shakespeare wrote. reading adaptations is utterly mssing the point of becoming well-read.
i never said
you didn't know how to read shakespeare, but i suggested that IF one didn't know, one should learn. which is another vital thing if one is trying to become well-read before entering college. a good way to learn to read shakespeare is to use study guides.