Sufjan = r0x0rs. I think the closest I've come to any kind of description of him is 'the lovechild of Bruce Springsteen and Nick Drake listening to prog rock in an instrument shop', and that barely does him justice.
On a Sufjan-related note:
Half-Handed Cloud
(he's the trombonist for the Illinoisemakers)
He's reminiscent of Sufjan in some ways but he also reminds me of the Apples in Stereo and a little bit of Neutral Milk Hotel and The Decembrists (good grief you Americans have a mighty fine indie scene). Just weird, quirky little songs that sound at first listen a bit flippant and silly, but have much greater depth when you can make out what he's singing. My personal favourite at the moment is 'So Busted Before Your Righteous Throne', but I've yet to hear anything bad by him.
And in case anyone had perchance been wondering about what my avatar & sig were all about:
Manic Street Preachers
Quite possibly the least popular British band in America- you guys don't know what you're missing! Their overall style is typical indie-rock, but their sound changes with each album- from G'n'R-style rock-outs, through stadium-pleasers, gothic punk, stripped-down 'rawk' and delicate electronically-influenced melodies, the Manics cover so many musical bases, but what makes them special are the lyrics- lyrics like you've never heard before. This is a band who can write songs about Willem de Koonig, Paul Robeson and Emily Pankhurst, who wear their alienation and their emotions right out on their sleeves, but can still have fun and write with hope despite their tragic history (one band member has been missing, presumed dead, for eleven years).
Songs to check out: well, all of them, but I'd particularly recommend Motorcycle Emptiness, Stay Beautiful, From Despair To Where, La Tristessa Durera, Yes, Faster, A Design For Life, No Surface All Feeling, Ready for Drowning, You Stole the Sun from My Heart, Let Robeson Sing, Masking Tape, 1985 and Empty Souls. Enjoy!
Signature, eh? We'll see about that...