Hmmm.
About Sam....he was obviously with TNT. What better way to annoy people, then to explain the clue fully before it is released. :-p. And really if you think about it, if you were to explain that clue to someone who isnt there yet, it would sound like rambling.
"The conundrum lenny drops by, and you steal the meepit by distracting the archivist, then you sneak into the archives and find a box of meepits. Then you go back to the archivist and steal his meepit again, and then the conun. lenny rips it open to find a blade. "
I do not believe that Finneus is the evil betrayer. I think most likely, that there was a reason Altador was locked away in time. Maybe something happened to Altador and the king sealed it away and "cursed" Finneus so that he would not remember the past, if the kingdom was ever restored. I kinda also think that by finding the constellations and lighting up the crystals is equivalent to opening a combination lock. But this one has 12 numbers instead of 3. :-p
Knowing how TNT works, after we find the 12th constellation, something/someone will come out and destroy altador...
And my thoughts on the club president. He's just a lonely jealous geek. Instead of coming back each time to say "Hey we just found ANOTHER constellation, na na na na
" we probably should have said something like "Hey bro, we're finding a lot of constellations, would you like me to show you how I'm finding them." Sadly, we are now beyond that point. I think he will explode in a jealous rage, tearing apart all the papers in the astronomy clu, therefore effectively ending the club...forcing us to join a different club. Maybe or Maybe Not?
Feel free to take the siggy^