Chii: Ooh, spiffy. I like the color scheme, cut-out, and layout, as well as the cool lines and BG. I would make the shoes a little more prominent (perhaps fade the bg a little?) and move the sig subtext a bit to the left so it doesn't interfere with the pic, and makes the sig look more balanced.
Fzun: Can't see them now, but I saw in your LJ and kept meaning to comment... I like the grey one best, with the orange one coming in second. Can't really do a proper rating now, as I can't see the pics.
Meowth: Can't see the pic, sorry.
Kim: Wow. Seriously, those are amazing. I love them both, especially Lillie's set. The animation works perfectly - it's beatiful, and adds to the set without being distracting. Hmmm... on Lillie's set I might make the subtext stand out a bit more, by stroking it or something, but it really looks fine as is because the background's fairly light. Can't really think of anything else.
Chaud: Hmm... I like the sig piccy... the av pic is interesting, but a little... I don't know...just strange. It's not bad, though. The fonts and composition in the sig are good, but the text is way too bright - you should fade it a bit. I would also get rid of the bright green/red borders, they're really distracting and don't match.
DM:
(set 1): This is my favorite of the ones here... I like the close focus of the picture, and the text overlay (although I'd tune it down a bit on the av). I would change the coloring of the text in both av and sig, which don't really match with the pic, and make the main sig text slightly more prominent, since that font is really skinny.
(set 2): The pic is kind of sloppily cut out, and it's really distracting - I'm also not crazy about the way you made the "fire" in the av black - I know you were trying for contrast, but it looks kind of odd. The BG is nice. The sig subtext, I'd go with another font.
(set 3): As you mentioned, the fire faerie is kind of pixelly. So is the text on the av, and the subtext on the sig, which are really bright and take up a lot of room - I'd go with a pixel font instead. Overall, my main complaint is that both the av and the sig look really cramped.
Shinigami: Preeetty! That's your first request? Ack, it's too good for that, you should have seen mine... uh, yeah, nevermind. I like the composition of the av - it's pretty original, and striking, and the insignia added over the face is a nice touch. The sig is nicely done too, although the edges of the shapes are a bit pixelly. Nice placement of the text, it's a little awkward, but I can't think of anywhere better any of it could have gone.
Maniac: In the av, I like the height, the text, and the gridding, but I'd take out the cut-outs at the bottom - they don't really help the image, and they don't match the sig. I'd also replace the white in the border with a pale yellow (that goes for the sig too). In the sig... hmm, I think I'd either space out the subtext, or move the main text down next to it. I'd also make the main text a contrasting color, like blue, to give the set some variety (if you did that, you could do the same for the av text).
Alex: Also not working.
So... what do you think? Picture taken by someone else, but severely edited by me. The sig was a lot spiffier when it was 93K, but I had to take out a lot of the animation. Hmph.
or
?
And