Pink Poogle Toy Forum

I'll try
'Like my hair?'

Considering xjox is in the UK, and it's past midnight there... I doubt it. ;_;

Xjox has until tomorrow to get her ratings in.

Jo hasn't been on for the last week. I wonder if she's ill?

Judge's Note: It was a tough decision between watericesage and Twinkle

watericesage
"Deserted, Forsaken, Alone..."

I believe this subtext truly captures the emotions of the set. It describes what the girl is feeling. Great subtext.

Rating: 8/10


Twinkle
"Drown my sorrows"

This was also a good subtext. This person is obviously feeling this way and I believe Twinkle's subtext was much more original than watericesage's.

Ratings: 9/10

Ledi
"Cold as ice, soft as silk"

I didn't think this really matched the set. It was an off-beat subtext.

Ratings: 4/10

Before I get to the judging, I just wanted to say that you all did a great job and congratulations for getting to the top three.

Watericesage -- Deserted, Forsaken, Alone...

I really like this one! It perfectly describes the girl in the signature and I could definitely see this going on the sig. The only complaint I have is, I feel it'd be better with fades between the three words instead of commas.

9 / 10

Twinkle -- Drown my sorrows

This would be a good subtext for the signature. Plus, the texture on the sig is kind of like water so the "drown" part ties in nicely. Your subtext is okay, but something about it just doesn't sound right... it's probably just my imagination though =P

8.5 / 10

Ledi -- Cold as ice, soft as silk

I can kiiind of see where you're going with this subtext, but then again, I can't really. It just doesn't make much sense to me, especially the "soft as silk" part. Maybe it's just me but, still. I just don't understand exactly what you're describing with your subtext.

6 / 10

Judges Notes: Well, first off congratulations to all three of you for making it this far, the three of you defiantly deserve to be here. Now, this was a tough signature to do, mainly because it can be perceived many different ways. You all did a good job, and I can see all these subtexts on this signature. It is the toughest choice of the competition. Well, here we go:

Watericesage---Deserted, Forsaken, Alone...
Whew, when you posted this I saw it and was like “WOW”. I really like this one, and you got the signature in a nut shell I think. Nice Job! 9.5/10

Ledi---Cool as ice, soft as silk
Excellent and I can see this fitting on the signature the best. The only little thing is that you didn’t incorporate the sadness of the signature into the subtext. The signature is very sad, and you incorporated everything but it in my opinion. Still a very good subtext and I congratulate you! 7.5/10

Twinkle---Drown my sorrows
Oooh, I had never seen the signature in this perspective before. It does in fact seem like she is drowning. It is an excellent subtext and I can see it on the signature. Nice job. 9/10

ROUND COMMENTS: It makes me so sad to see this end. ;_; I love all of your works, and to the two runners up- you'd better join up next time because the both of you (whoever you are) have beautiful style and potential.

Watericesage: "Deserted, forsaken, alone"

I like it. It really describes the mood of the set excellently, and what the girl appears to be feeling. Could be a tiny bit more original, but quite honestly- no complaints here. Very good job.

I give it an 8/10.

Twinkle: "Drown my Sorrows"

Twinkle, whether you win or not, I really think you're great at subtexts. I've seen some truly fantastic work from you, and you are overall a really wonderful asset to this competition. I'd also like to say that even through a bunch of emotional roller coasters you must have gone through due to real life happenings during this competition, you stood strong and you didn't give up. I really respect you for that. As for the subtext, I love it. I think it's very original and describes very well.

I give it a 9.5/10.

Ledi: "Cool as ice, soft as silk"

You were one of my favorites in the beginning, but I must say this subtexts disappoints me. It doesn't really describe anything but the background, and there are much, much more important things to describe than the background.

I give it a 4/10.

Alrighty.

I'll have them up momentarily.