Xyzzy, if this happens "all the time" on games that you play on another forum, then I would think about giving some tips on how
not to make a game. The dreamer is useless if you're playing a bunch of games where their dreams mean diddly squat, so why even have them? It's absolutely pointless. There should definitely be moderation in how often dreams can be changed. One out of ten games sounds about right.
Plus, as I've already said, your defense is crud, and you're just spouting the same thing as 9/10 people that come up with a defense when they're dreamt of use. Guess what? There probably aren't very many innocents left anyway (I'm guesing over half are evil, unless we have a one person advantage on them)! There are at probably at LEAST 6 baddies left (maybe 5).
Also, if you really wanted to come up with a defense, you would have named your role already... and well, you haven't. You've just been spouting "I'm not evil, the dream is wrong!"
Edit: I would like to correct myself on the "never seen a dream changed" comment. I HAVE seen one incident in which a dream was changed with no powers saying it was. It was because someone had a role that they didn't know of (I think called the miller? I don't remember), where they were a plain innocent, and that person would be dreamt of as evil without nay reason as to why.
However, I doubt May would implement or even know of such a thing, as I've only seen it once in one of Matt's games.
Edit: Scratch that, Dyl's probably good, then. I'd look into Okamoto, though, and probably ckillor. ckillor hasn't been terrible active and he survived a shot (though it could easily be coincidence), and if he were on a baddie team, then his shield would not go down for missing lists. If he did fail to turn lists in (which is just an assumption), then he shouldn't have much of a shield left?
Just a huge guess, though.
(Oh, and I think Okamoto is Sylar. Also, don't forget that Twiz has been attacked a couple of times too (one by vigi, once at night). Personally I would at least execute Twiz today, but that's only because I really have no better ideas.

)